Report / SSF WORKSHOP
Implementation of the FAO SSF Guidelines, through appropriate legislation, would go a long way to help shore up the livelihoods of the small-scale fisherfolk of Pakistan
This article is by Muhammed Ali Shah (email@example.com), and Roshan Bhatti (firstname.lastname@example.org) of Pakistan Fisherfolk Forum (PFF), Karachi, Pakistan
The Committee on Fisheries (COFI) of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), at its Thirty-first Session in June 2014, formally adopted the Voluntary Guidelines for Securing Sustainable Small-scale Fisheries in the Context of Food Security and Poverty Eradication (SSF Guidelines).
The International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD), a specialized agency of the United Nations, granted a project in December 2015 to a consortium comprising the World Forum of Fisher Peoples (WFFP), the World Forum of Fish Harvesters and Fish Workers (WFF), the International Collective in Support of Fishworkers (ICSF) and Centro Internazionale Crocevia (CIC) to promote awareness about the SSF Guidelines and to mobilize support for their implementation across countries of the Global South.
The National Workshop on Capacity-building for the Implementation of the SSF Guidelines, held in Karachi, was the first in a series in Pakistan as part of the efforts to mobilize support for the implementation of the SSF Guidelines.
The workshop was organized by the Pakistan Fisherfolk Forum in collaboration with WFFP at Hotel Regent Plaza, Karachi during 24-25 August 2016.
The participants of the national workshop included: women and men leaders of inland, marine and coastal fisheries; fishworkers and fishing communities from across the entire country; representatives of federal and provincial agencies, particularly those dealing with fisheries, environment, labour, trade and human development; representatives of civil society organizations (CSOs) and NGOs, scientific organizations, and the representatives of FAO, IFAD, ILO and others in Pakistan.
At the outset, the participants paid tribute to the late Tahira Ali Shah, the PFF’s leader who lost her life in March 2015 during one of the major campaigns of PFF. Her struggle for the uplift of the marginalized fishing and peasant communities of Pakistan was acknowledged at the occasion.
Jamil Junejo, Manager, Programmes of the PFF, welcomed all the participants of the workshop. Muhammad Ali Shah, Chairperson, PFF and WFFP, gave a detailed and technical presentation on the SSF Guidelines. He said the major role of the guidelines was to move towards responsible fisheries. Until and unless this objective is achieved, we cannot save the fisheries and protect the lives of the fisher people, he said. He also presented the history and salient features of the SSF Guidelines.
The opening session discussed implementation of the guiding principles of the SSF Guidelines, human-rights laws and the constitution of Pakistan. Mir Hasil Khan Bizanjo, the Federal Minister for Port and Shipping, was the key speaker. Small-scale fishermen suffer from starvation while the mafia is depleting the marine resources badly, said the federal minister. He further added that the use of the destructive nets is a major threat to small-scale fishing and must be banned. Sindh and Baluchistan governments should take notice of it, he suggested.
The Minister for Livestock and Fisheries Sindh, Muhammad Ali Malkani, said that until and unless there is an effective endorsement of the SSF Guidelines from all stakeholders, implementation will be a challenge. He announced that the Sindh government would soon establish a Fisheries Advisory Council for which he seeks guidance of the fishing communities.
Haji Shafi Muhammad Jamote, member of the Sindh Assembly, said that the human and industrial waste in the canal waters and the sea was affecting the common citizens and marine resources. He said overfishing was a big issue and suggested that industrialists be discouraged from fishing and the small-scale bona fide fishermen be encouraged.
Nasar Hayat, Assistant Representative, Head of Progaramme, FAO Pakistan, said that every legislation is made for the benefit of the small-scale fishers and they should be made part of it. Under the SSF Guidelines, access to resources is the basis for poverty alleviation in the world and these Guidelines were made under such a programme. If people have sustainable access to resources, they will have food security and their poverty would also reduce. Pakistan was part of the process of the SSF Guidelines in a significant way during the consultation phase. Pakistan has a big role in the development of the SSF Guidelines and now it is the responsibility of the government to implement it in their legislation. He assured the technical assistance of FAO, if required at any level.
Aly Ercelan, senior researcher, said that national policy on food security is under the consideration of the federal government as well as in the provinces. The SSF Guidelines should be seriously taken into account. At the federal level, a draft of the policy is not enough. Natural resources should be used in a way that they are not wasted and the policy should follow the SSF Guidelines.
Social Development, Employment and Decent Work for Responsible/Sustainable Fisheries
Caroline Bates, Officer-in-Charge, ILO, said oceans are resources for fish and sources of livelihood. In many countries, fishing is the only way of eking out a livelihood. So, decent working conditions for the fishing community are essential. She said that providing decent working conditions to the fishing community was part of ratification and implementation of the ILO conventions. However, Pakistan has not yet ratified the Work in Fishing Convention, 200 (No. 188).
Saeed Baloch, Secretary General, PFF, said under the Sustainable Development Goals 2030, ILO discusses improvement of working conditions of the workers. However, fishermen have not been considered. The social development of fishworkers, including basic amenities of living, has not been provided for. Female workers should get equal wages and must not face harassment. He said the sustainable fisheries policy in Pakistan should also focus on these matters in the light of the SSF Guidelines.
Khawer Parvez Awan, Director Inland Fisheries, Sindh, said until all stakeholders, including fishermen, boatowners and the government, work together, decent work would not become practical. He said the Sindh government fully supports the SSF Guidelines.
Zulfiqar Shah, Co-director, Pakistan Institute of Labour Education and Research, said that work of fishermen is no more a decent work in the conditions they are currently working in. After the 18th amendment of the Constitution, labour issues in Pakistan are to be sorted out by the labour department. He said that PFF model is effective. He urged FAO and ILO to push the Pakistan government towards the implementation of the SSF Guidelines.
Tenure rights to land and water bodies, livelihoods and responsible/sustainable fisheries in light of national and international laws, especially the Voluntary Guidelines on the Responsible Governance of Tenure of Land, Fisheries and Forests in the context of National Food Security
Representatives from the following governmental and civil society organizations participated in the discussion: fishing community persons; the Fisheries Departments of Baluchistan, Sindh and Punjab provinces; Marine Fisheries, WWF-Pakistan; IUCN and the Labour Adviser to the Chief Minister, Balochistan.
The current status of actions under relevant laws remains inadequate, missing or adverse as compared to those required to acknowledge and promote livelihoods of peasants, in general, and fishers, in particular, when compared to the Tenure Guidelines of Land, Fisheries and Forests. Fishers are even more insecurely placed than land-based peasants, though perhaps the latter are often more harshly treated by landowners and the state than are fishers. The SSF Guidelines could and should be used but they have not resulted in a Food Security Policy that is serious about eradicating hunger and malnutrition. Agrarian reforms that include redistribution of access to water and land have not been seriously reconsidered since the 1970s. In the face of current threats to tenure, compensation for voluntary displacement remains a distant hope for fishersof which two examples are most odious: the continuing land and water grabs of the Defence Housing Authority, and forced dispossession of fishers by new housing and industrial schemes on the Sindh Coast such as the Zulfikarabad city scheme and the Special Economic Zones.
Natural and Man-made disasters and Climate change
Experts on environmental governance, representatives from the Meteorological Department, the National Institute of Oceanography, the Provincial Disaster Management Authority and others participated in the discussion. It was noted that climate change was not a sudden occurrence. Anthropogenic activities have increased carbon discharge or emissions. Developed countries are creating a fund that would give US$1 bn annually to the developing countries for the purpose of mitigation and adaptation to climate change. Natural disasters would be of short duration but they would be intense. As per the research conducted by IUCN, which was also endorsed by the Senate of Pakistan, sea intrusion will adversely affect the coast of Sindh by 2030 and 2060. It was suggested that the
Protecting life and livelihoods: SSF Guidelines for legislation, policies and research for fisheries and fishing communities
Muhammad Ali Shah said the SSF Guidelines are an instrument of FAO. Around 200 mn fishermen in the world depend on fisheries, of which 90 per cent of are small-scale fishermen. Their future is endangered. Now, the time has come for responsible fisheries. FAO has realized it and the issue of food security would be addressed through the SSF Guidelines. The goal cannot be achieved without the participation of fisher communities. The fisheries authorities of many countries have endorsed the SSF Guidelines.
A responsible fishery is not only the responsibility of the government, he said, but also of all other stakeholders. Participatory policies should be formed and the SSF Guidelines present an example of participatory guidelines. He sought a national commission on the implementation of the SSF Guidelines. He endorsed the Advisory Council suggested by the provincial minister. The Director General of Fisheries of all the four provinces must be part of it. Representatives of the fisheries sector and environmentalists must be part of it. The SSF Guidelines are meant for the whole country. Consultation meetings for Baluchistan and Sindh would soon be called.
The participants of the workshop unanimously agreed on the formation of a committee for the implementation and legislation on the SSF Guidelines. The committee would communicate with the participants of the workshop and the legislators, in order to enact a law for the implementation of the SSF Guidelines under the local circumstances. The committee would write letters to the concerned people in this regard and the process of the implementation of the SSF Guidelines would be carried forward.
Pakistan: Implementation of the Voluntary Guidelines for Securing Sustainable Small-scale Fisheries in the context of Food Security and Poverty Eradication (SSF Guidelines)